Simple Fitness, Food and Health Hacks

Hey, I'm Julien. Each week I share a newsletter designed to make you fitter. It's short, smart and actionable16k read it, I'd love you to join too. It's free.

The Calorie-Torching Truth: Which Machine Melts More Fat, the Climber or the Rower?

 Written by 

Julien Raby

 Last updated on 

We may receive a commission from our affiliate links at no additional cost to you. See disclosures page.


Get ready to climb to new heights or row your way to a stronger you!

Ever wondered which is better between the vertical climber and the rower? Discover the secrets to maximizing your workouts and reaching your fitness goals.

CLIMBER-VS-ROWER
  • Save

Uncover the surprising truth about which machine burns more calories, builds more muscle, and is best for weight loss.

Don’t miss out on this head-to-head comparison that will revolutionize the way you think about cardio. The answer might surprise you!

Climber vs Rower Specifications

There are important technical differences between climbers and rowers. It all comes down to their function. 

Best Rower for Beginner
Sunny Water Rowing Machine
4.5

Based on our testing, this is the best rower for beginners. For less than 500$, this silent water rower will last you for years. It also comes with a 12-year warranty.

Pros:
  • Affordable
  • Quiet
  • Amazing warranty
See latest price See all Rowers below 500$

Climbing workouts can be on a stair stepper or a vertical climber. Stair climbers involve the legs, while vertical climbers involve your entire body. 

The purpose of a vertical climber is to mimic the climbing motion. It’s a tall, thin machine with rungs on either side. To use, place your feet on the pedals and hold the top handlebars. You can naturally shift your weight as your arms pull while your legs push, one side at a time.

Indoor rowing machines simulate the feeling of rowing indoors. Using the rower begins from a seated position. Then, pull the bar towards you while moving the legs in unison to gain momentum.

Many types of climbers and rowing machines are available, catering to different budgets and preferences.

Display information

Higher-end machines will have greater adjustability and features than budget machines, including fitness apps, and a range of options to track distance, calories burned, and heart rate.

Resistance

Depending on the model, some devices will have an adjustable resistance while others are fixed.

Adjustability

People with a heavier body weight will need to look for a machine that caters to their size and weight, ensuring they remain safe and stable on the floor.

Size

Bulky rowing machines are harder to store, but those with wheels are easier to move around. While some vertical climbers can be stored away, making them a functional option for those short on space.

Benefits of Vertical Climbers

image 15
  • Save

Climber machines are an intriguing option and offer a great cardio workout.

The list of advantages includes:

  • According to Sports Journal, stair climbing lowers body weight and improves aerobic fitness
  • Provides all-over body benefits including strength training just by changing the resistance
  • Considered a low-impact workout safe for people with joint or back issues
  • Offers similar benefits to rock climbing, including increased body conditioning and upper body strength. Great for people training for outdoor climbing 

Disadvantages

  • Getting into the climbing rhythm requires coordination and balance. Getting used to this can take time
  • If there are no options to increase the resistance they can go too fast.
  • Lack of resistance also affects your workout goals if you want to gain muscle
  • Currently, there is no scientific research on the specific health benefits and long-term results of vertical climbers 

Benefits of Rowers 

image 16
  • Save

Indoor rowers are popular cardio machines for a reason. 

Key advantages include: 

  • Improves postural strength by increasing strength in the upper back, according to research from the Hallym University College of Medicine
  • Combines aerobic exercise and strength building to provide a full-body exercise
  • Considered a low-impact machine, great for those unable to do exercises like running
  • Suitable for those training for outdoor rowing
  • Studies have proven health benefits, including cardiovascular and lung health, and reducing the risk of illness and disease 

Disadvantages

  • Rowing machines can be noisy
  • Hip issues can arise if the knees bow out to the side. Keep them straight and neutral
  • Keeping a correct posture can be harder to maintain with increased tension
  • Poor form can trigger back pain

Climbers vs Rowers for Building Muscle?

It is possible to gain some muscle mass with cardio machines. Note that climbers and rowers both work a range of muscle groups, including most of the major groups.

Primary muscle groups include:

  • Lower body and legs (Glutes, hip flexors, hamstrings, quads, and calf muscle groups)
image 17
  • Save
  • Upper body (Erector spinae, abdominal muscles, upper and lower back, traps, pecs)
image 18
  • Save
  • Arms muscles (including biceps, triceps, brachialis, and forearms)
image 19
  • Save

Climbing

The hip flexors, core muscles, and other secondary muscle groups also work during the movement.

If you want to target your lower body, keep your arms stationary and only use the lower rungs. Similarly, you can also vary the grip on the top handlebars to target different upper-body muscles.

Increasing the resistance will turn an aerobic workout into an anaerobic workout that fatigues the muscles. If this is your goal, work at high-intensity intervals, rest, and repeat.

Rowing

image 20
  • Save

In a study from the English Institute of Sport, researchers found that rowing engages 86% of muscles in the body.

Rowing is resistance training that helps increase muscle toning. Research shows around 30-45 minutes of increased resistance at high intensity works best.

Much of the work happens at the start of the pull motion. Meaning muscle recruitment in the chest, anterior deltoids, and triceps is minimal. So if you want to hit your whole body, jump off the rower into a set of push-ups before getting back on again.

image 21
  • Save

Alt text (digital image of man in push-up position highlighting the chest, anterior deltoids, and triceps muscles)

Cardio exercise machines won’t specifically help you increase muscle strength. But you’ll still see powerful benefits, and fitness beginners will see the most increase in additional muscle mass compared to seasoned athletes.

Vertical Climber Machine vs Rowing Machine For Weight Loss?

Possibly the biggest reason people choose vertical climbing is that it offers a high-calorie burn. According to scientific study, whole-body simulated climbing elicits a higher VO2max than rowing, which is the maximum amount of oxygen used during exercise, and a way of measuring aerobic fitness levels. That means climbing offers a greater physiological challenge. And a higher heart rate will lead to greater fitness.

Best Rower for Beginner
Sunny Water Rowing Machine
4.5

Based on our testing, this is the best rower for beginners. For less than 500$, this silent water rower will last you for years. It also comes with a 12-year warranty.

Pros:
  • Affordable
  • Quiet
  • Amazing warranty
See latest price See all Rowers below 500$

That’s why climbers are a great piece of equipment for those wanting to lose weight. And it has a slight advantage over the rower. Just a 30-minute session can burn between 300-800 calories.

In comparison, the rower burns fewer calories, around 200-300 per 30-minute workout.

Note that despite these figures, measuring the number of calories burned during a workout is difficult to calculate because there are so many contributing factors, such as weight, age, heart rate, intensity, and time.

The vertical climber may burn more calories. But using the rower will also help you slim down everywhere too, including your belly.

To burn calories on either machine, go for HIIT-style workouts. Go hard for a set amount of time, followed by a rest. Repeat this in sets without leaving anything in the tank.

Climber vs Rower: The Final Verdict 

While many studies have proven the benefits of stair climbing, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a lot of peer-reviewed studies on vertical climbers. Modern rowing machines have been around for decades. And thousands of studies have proven its efficiency in providing quality cardio with muscle-building workouts. Due to this, if you only choose one machine, we recommend the rower. It comes close to the perfect exercise machine because it offers more proven all-around fitness results.

But either way, rowers and climbers each offer an excellent full-body workout since all major muscle groups are utilized, so don’t cross the climber off your workout list just yet.

About

Julien Raby is the owner of BoxLife. He owns a bachelor in literature and a certificate in marketing from Concordia. He's Crossfit Level 1 certified and has been involved in Crossfit since 2010. In 2023 he finally made it to Crossfit Open Quarterfinals for the first time. LinkedIn Instagram Facebook

Share via
Copy link